Skip to content

Category: Dog game

地狱之刃让你成为什么样的人

本文由 Paolo Gambardella 以意大利语撰写,由 AI 智能体翻译,可能含有不准确之处。

2026年6月中旬,就在Ninja Theory还在Xbox发布会上展示自己下一款游戏的同时,微软内部已经在讨论是否要关闭这家工作室。

据彭博社及多家媒体证实的消息来源,Ninja Theory、Double Fine和Compulsion Games目前正在就从微软回购独立性一事进行谈判。(来源:IGN、Kotaku)

微软的说法

6月10日,Xbox新任CEO Asha Sharma发布了一份内部备忘录,随后被公开:“Next 100 Days: Xbox Reset”。那种”企业式坦诚”的腔调,与其说是在分享愿景,不如说是在为裁员做铺垫。

文中列举的数字很难无视:

  • Xbox在五年内向内容、平台和硬件投入了超过200亿美元
  • 同期年营收下滑近5亿美元
  • 2026年预计利润率约为3%,较上年进一步下降
  • 硬件存储成本两年内翻了五倍

文件提到了”过度扩张的工作室矩阵”,强调需要速度、利润率以及有保障的年度发布管线。Sharma来自EA,以数据驱动的管理风格著称。这套逻辑套到Ninja Theory身上,结果可想而知。

把工作做好反而成了悖论

然而真正让人唏嘘的地方在于,Ninja Theory恰恰做到了我们一直被告知应该做的事:建立鲜明的艺术身份,拥抱创作风险,做出那种让整个行业由衷尊重、口碑延续多年的游戏。但创作上的卓越,并不能对冲预算层面的决策。

时代变了。大公司收购工作室是为了整合目录资产,一旦账面不好看就开始优化。2018年的Ninja Theory(刚被微软收购,对未来充满期待)和2026年的Ninja Theory,区别不在于他们做了什么,而在于他们所处的财务环境彻底变了。

这个教训听起来不太好受,但对所有在这个行业工作的人都适用:把工作做好是必要条件,但不是充分条件。真正的保障来自别的地方:利润率、市场定位、财务自主性。和设计质量的关系不大。

话虽如此,把工作做好依然是你唯一真正能掌控的事。这篇文章,某种程度上,也是对那些把工作做到极致的人致以的一点敬意。

Ninja Theory留下了什么:一个分析框架

我没有和Ninja Theory合作过,但和很多业内人士一样,我一直在认真关注他们在做什么。下面的分析,是我试图搞清楚他们的作品为什么能成立。

Ninja Theory的核心优势在于他们交付给玩家的幻想。这个区分,无论是开发团队内部还是外部,很多人都没搞清楚。

在我的咨询工作中,最常见的问题之一就是:团队能把自己的游戏说清楚——机制是什么、属于什么类型、美术风格如何——但就是答不上那个最根本的问题:

你让玩家成为了什么?

不是”玩家做了什么”(动词和系统)。不是”游戏讲了什么”(主题和叙事)。而是:玩家在游玩过程中变成了什么?他们身处哪一种幻想之中?

案例分析:《地狱之刃——塞娜的献祭》

分析对象:《地狱之刃:塞娜的献祭》,Ninja Theory,2017年,完整产品。

表层设定幻想: Ninja Theory谈到了”体验式叙事”,谈到要以真实的方式呈现精神病体验(有精神科顾问参与),谈到这是一个关于凯尔特女战士的第三人称游戏。从表面看,幻想大致是”女战士 + 黑暗旅途 + 北欧神话”。

玩家的动词——你在循环里真正做什么

在《地狱之刃》里,玩家:

  • 在充满敌意、时常令人迷失方向的环境中前行
  • 通过幻象和声音(复仇三女神)来感知世界——它们评论、欺骗、警告
  • 在风景中寻找形状来解开视觉谜题——但答案从来都不是客观确定的,那是你自己的解读
  • 在看似不可能取胜、敌人不断再生的情况下战斗
  • 背负着一个重量(字面意义上的:狄利恩的头骨),永远无法放下

这些动词里,没有一个是”成为强大的战士”。没有一个承诺那种传统意义上的掌控感或熟练度。

情感承诺

《地狱之刃》最好的时刻,不是你赢得一场战斗的瞬间。而是你在一切重压之下仍然走了下去。尽管有那些声音。尽管有那种被注视、被评判的感觉。尽管面对一个拒绝被理解的世界。

情感承诺是:在内心痛苦中依然坚持。

把幻想和表层皮相剥离开

去掉北欧神话。去掉维京人。去掉赫尔海姆。

剩下的是:一个感知世界的方式与他人不同的人,必须带着这种扭曲继续行动,而且没有停下来。

这才是核心幻想。它和世界观设定完全无关。它是系统层面的,不是装饰性的。

幻想的裂缝

最大的风险藏在战斗环节。在某些段落里,玩家可能会感受到那种动作游戏传统意义上的”我很强”的感觉。一旦出现这种感觉,”带着精神病症在挣扎中活下去”的幻想就会产生裂缝。

Ninja Theory的应对方式是在战斗过程中也维持着高强度的视听压迫感。但这是个很微妙的平衡。如果他们为了和其他动作游戏竞争而加深战斗系统的深度,这个幻想大概率就会被打破。

选择把战斗做得简单,不是技术上的局限。这是一个服务于核心幻想的设计决策。

设计层面的推论

从《地狱之刃》的核心幻想出发,可以直接推导出三个设计原则:

  1. 不要给玩家太多掌控感——一旦玩家觉得自己掌控了局面,内部压力下求生存的幻想就会弱化
  2. 声音必须和游戏玩法产生交互——不是背景调味,而是能在实时状态下影响玩家决策的元素
  3. 避免任何明确的”正确答案”——这个幻想依赖于感知上的模糊性;一个清晰的HUD或直白的新手引导会直接把它摧毁

结语

微软算了一笔账,发现Ninja Theory对于Xbox已经建立的这种规模来说,盈利能力不够充分。但有一件事是数字捕捉不到的:Ninja Theory知道如何回答游戏设计中最难的问题——”你让玩家变成了什么?”

如果这个工作室就此关闭,我们失去的是行业里为数不多真正明白这件事的声音:玩家幻想比机制更重要,比类型更重要。或许从长远来看,也比利润率更重要。

Today is a good day

Yesterday under the shower, I had an “eureka” moment. Now I can continue with a project I had put on pause, because I have a new vision to work on. This breakthrough was possible because I put hours into studying a tool– a completely different kind of task. My mind started connecting the dots, and after a couple of “let’s try this…” attempts, I got it.

I am happy; now I have renewed energies to work on this.

Continuous patrolling in Pawtners Case

Yesterday, I got the third prototype for my game Pawtners Case. I have this design pillar, which is called “continuous patrol”. One of the objectives of the ideation stage and pre-production is to decide on design pillars that will guide the rest of the production and launch.

That means that I don’t want to have a main menu. You run the game, you are in the game. Most games do not need a main menu, especially nowadays when loading a game takes so much times and connections.

Also, there is no death condition. You can fall off the level (imagine levels are islands in the sky) and land on the same level again. I am also thinking of minigames to do.

Credits will be integrated into the game, too. You can ignore them, but you don’t have to skip them.

Pawtners Case first blockout

This week I have worked intensively on my indie game, Pawtners Case. You are a police dog and you have to help your colleagues to solve cases.

The first level I am prototyping is a medium one. The goal is straightforward, you need to reunite with your colleague, Agent Quinn, and escape a warehouse. There is a bomb to dismantle, too.

This week I have implemented a lot of features, and a blockout. You can see the result here:

For the blockout, I started by looking for references and setting up a moodboard:

Then, I proceeded to create a notepad where I defined my goals, the sequence, and so on. Later I created a map:

Then, in Unreal Engine I set up the level, iterating on the concept. I have to say that I find Unreal Engine versatile for a game designer. It has integrated a gameplay framework that makes things easier. I am happy with my choice!

Pawtners Case

Today I have completed a set of new mechanics which will be useful for the very first prototype of my game. You can watch here:

I have also changed the name of the game, after listening to the first feedback on a Discord server. The game will be called Pawtners Case, I am studying also layouts for a possible capsule. This is what I got so far:

I am impressed by Unreal Engine. I don’t know why I didn’t use it until now. It has a whole gameplay framework already implemented, you can set things up very easily. And placing object in the level is fairly simple. It doesn’t have the huge community that Unity has, but it’s a powerful tool.

Now I need to focus on the level for the first prototype, and double check which mechanics I am missing.

Snifferson & Solvito: Paws on the case

I discovered that AEVI, a local association that helps game developers in Spain, activated a help plan for independent developers. They help you financially with the development of a prototype.

My first solo dev game in Unreal Engine is taking shape! I am excited, and I am willing to keep things very small and doable. I want to make a complete game in 6 months, and I can add 2 more for QA and debugging but that’s it.

My intention is to keep things fairly simple:

  • You control a police dog and your goal is to help your human companion solve a case
  • No dialogues, just emojis to express emotions. I want to avoid too many terms to translate. You can develop a relationship with your human colleague which will help you during levels
  • As a dog, you can find valuable items (+$) but also damage the environments (-$) and this will influence the economy of the central station
  • Everytime you perform some action you will learn more abilities during the level which can be useful to solve the case, so you decide
  • No violence, PEGI 12, E10+ game. Explosions and shots will be funny using ragdolls and silly animations

Dog game

When I was younger I was addicted to TV shows with a policeman and a dog. The most famous one was called Tequila & Bonetti. I still remember that piano music that Bonetti played at night, recalling his dark past.

I am studying Unreal Engine and I had an idea: an action game with a story where you are the dog and have to solve situations to move forward with the story.

For now it’s called simply “Dog game”, I am implementing the first mechanics.

Follow here the development of this game