Skip to content

Tag: insight

How I Would Monetize a F2P Game for Kids in 2028

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

In my last post I wrote that without pay-to-win and pay-to-progress, free-to-play doesn’t hold up. Today I’m setting myself a design exercise instead: how would I monetise an F2P game for a PEGI 12 audience in 2028, with the new Digital Fairness Act in force?

Rules of the exercise

  • PEGI 12 audience, so predominantly minors
  • no paid loot boxes
  • no pay-to-win and no pay-to-progress
  • in-game currencies off by default, only switched on with parental consent
  • prices shown in euros

The starting point

I’m taking a genre I know well: a casual mobile game with social features, along the lines of Monopoly GO!. Initial team of 8–15 people, with ambitions to grow to over 400.

Monopoly GO! makes most of its money from two things. Dice — the energy you buy to roll more and move faster around the board: textbook pay-to-progress. And sticker packs with random contents, which are effectively loot boxes. For a PEGI 12 audience, under the draft rules, both of those go out the window.

That leaves the question everything else hinges on: should sessions be capped or not? I think yes. Without a cap the game loses its rhythm — but I can no longer sell the cap itself.

Playing and progressing, kept separate

I’d try to separate playing from progressing. Each day there’s a progress cap, the same for everyone and free. You play your rounds, advance around the board, collect your rewards. Once you hit the cap you can keep playing, but from that point the base game gives you nothing more.

After the cap, the daily endgames open up: paid modes with different boards, different rules, special events. One rule applies throughout:

You pay to get in; once you’re in, everyone’s on equal footing.

Whatever you earn in a premium mode stays in the premium modes and never feeds back into the base game. Inside, there’s nothing you can buy to go faster — otherwise I’d have just moved the pay-to-progress problem sideways. It’s the same principle as an expansion pack: you buy access to new content, and once you’re in, you compete on the same terms as everyone else.

Explorers and Achievers

In the endgames I’d include achievements: badges, titles, profile frames. They exist purely to be shown off and have no effect on gameplay whatsoever. The Achiever buys the chance to earn them — like paying an entry fee for a race, knowing you still have to win the medal yourself.

For Explorers, who in classic F2P I never monetised well, I’d put in secrets: rare combinations, board areas that almost nobody has ever reached, hidden rules you only discover by playing. This is an audience I used to leave on the table, and here they become actual customers.

The monetisation for Killers I’d leave entirely to parents — and only to parents — in case they want to join their kids in an alternative version of the game, rated PEGI 18.

The customer is the parent

With currencies off by default, whoever pays is always the parent. The kid has the desire, the parent has the card and has to give consent. So I need to persuade two people with very different motivations: the child wants what their friends already have, the parent wants to know exactly how much they’ll spend and whether their child is playing too much.

No dark patterns in communications or pop-ups — by 2028 that’ll be the law, so it barely counts as a virtue. To genuinely reassure parents you need something proactive, and I’d treat it as a product feature:

  • a monthly spending cap set by the parent
  • a summary of what their child has bought and how long they’ve played
  • a fixed-price subscription, approved once, instead of a stream of individual microtransactions to approve one by one

Then there’s an idea I’ve already hinted at. Monopoly was born as a family board game — parents and kids around the same table. So the parent can enter the game as a player: family sessions, gifts, a family subscription with multiple profiles. A parent who plays alongside their child knows what they’re buying, and is much more likely to say yes.

One condition: it’s the child who invites them.

At 12–14, very few kids want a parent watching while they play with their friends. If the involvement were imposed, I’d be taking away the very thing I’m trying to monetise cleanly — the child’s autonomy. And on top of that, the game would instantly become “the one where your parents are”, which for a twelve-year-old is basically a death sentence.

The model in brief

Free: the base game, with a daily progress cap.

Paid: access to the daily endgames, with achievements to show off and secrets to uncover. Once inside, everyone plays on equal terms.

Running across both: cosmetics, a subscription (including a family tier), gifts between friends and between parent and child. No randomness: you always know exactly what you’re buying.

The verdict

According to self-determination theory, we play to satisfy three needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. Classic F2P sells all three. In this exercise I’m selling autonomy — through cosmetics and mode access — competence remains tied to the premium modes (though I can’t sell victory), and relatedness through gifts and family play.

I don’t know how much a game like this could make — let’s say one tenth. One tenth is enough for a fifteen-person team to get by on, and get by well. A team of four hundred or more, as is the case with Monopoly GO!, is a different story entirely.

Without pay-to-win, free-to-play shrinks.

To the small European studio I was advising two days ago to make a different type of game entirely, today I’d say something more precise. F2P is still doable, as long as you design it to stay small from day one — with an audience, a catalogue, and a team built for that scale. The ambition of becoming the next Monopoly GO!, under this legislation, in Europe, targeting kids? I’d let that one go.

How would you monetise it? Any angles I’ve missed? Feel free to drop me a message on LinkedIn.

Free-to-play Can’t Survive Without Pay-to-Win

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

Today a draft of the Digital Fairness Act leaked — the regulation the European Commission wants to use to rewrite online consumer protection. It was first published by the French outlet Contexte, then picked up by Euronews and AFP. I read about it on PocketGamer.biz. The official presentation is scheduled for 11 November.

What the draft says

For minors:

  • paid loot boxes banned
  • pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanics banned
  • in-game currencies off by default, only enabled with parental consent

For everyone:

  • the value of virtual currencies must be shown in real money
  • loot box odds must be disclosed
  • adults can disable features designed to push compulsive spending

Fines go up to 6% of global turnover. Some analyses also suggest that a PEGI rating under 18 is enough to indicate that minors are using the game. Worth bearing in mind that almost every mobile game today is PEGI 3, 7, or 12.

This is still a draft. It needs to go through Parliament and Council, and would apply twelve months after coming into force.

I won’t take a stance on whether it’s right or wrong — I trust the institutions and the research they’ve done. What interests me is what happens next, and here’s my read.

Without pay-to-win or pay-to-progress, free-to-play doesn’t work.

In F2P, the game itself is free. Access to the fun is free by definition, and rightly so — it’s how you get as many people in the door as possible. What players pay for is something else: winning, getting ahead, being the best. In every F2P I’ve worked on, without exception, spending was concentrated wherever there was something to win or somewhere to advance to.

The psychology backs this up neatly. According to self-determination theory, we play to satisfy three needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. F2P monetises all three: choosing a costume (skin), the feeling of being good at something, and comparing yourself to others — the leaderboard, the clan, the gaze of people below you. It’s even clearer through Bartle’s player types. The ones who spend are mostly Achievers, who want to progress, and Killers, who want to dominate or at least exert some kind of power over others. Take away pay-to-progress from the first group and pay-to-win from the second, and you’re left with a free game and very few paying customers.

What about Fortnite?

This is always the first objection: Fortnite makes billions selling only skins. But Fortnite launched at exactly the right moment and slotted into a business model — Epic’s — that would be unsustainable for any normal developer: a proprietary engine, a store, licensing deals, a global audience built over years.

And I’m not even sure it’s actually profitable. In March 2026, Epic laid off more than a thousand people, citing Fortnite’s decline and admitting it spends more than it earns. The same had already happened in 2023, with around 830 redundancies. If the cosmetics-only model is struggling there, imagine trying it at a fifteen-person studio.

The big players will manage. They make money in North America, Asia, and the Middle East, and can either adapt their European version or take the hit. For small and mid-sized European teams it’s a different story: the home market becomes the place where their business model, for a large chunk of the audience, is no longer legal.

That’s why, if I were talking to a small team today, I’d say one thing: you’re better off making a different kind of game.

Key takeaway

I don’t know what studios will do. Raise the PEGI rating, add age verification, ship a Europe-only version, pull out of the market altogether — I genuinely can’t predict it. What I do know is that a law like this, even if it changes along the way, reshapes the space you’re designing in. If you’re making F2P in Europe, it’s worth starting to think about this now, before the game is finished and the law is in force.

What’s your take? If you’re working on an F2P in Europe, what will you change? Feel free to message me directly on LinkedIn.

Clone a Game with AI: Should This Be Done?

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

Mark Brown, the creator of Game Maker’s Toolkit, has published a video in which he tells a story that could apply to anyone making games today, big studios or solo devs alike.

What happened

Two Hungarian developers, working as a hobby project, used Claude Code to build a word game that they themselves describe as “Word Play with a bunch of extra stuff on top”. Word Play is the word roguelike Mark released in 2025. It took them eleven days, and they added a time mode, a daily challenge, multiplayer, and a meta-progression system. Before doing anything with it, they emailed Mark to ask what he thought, and promised to keep the game private if he wasn’t comfortable with it.

Mark spent twenty minutes thinking out loud: he’s losing money on it, clones have always existed, he’s not a fan of AI, and their game is better than his in some respects. In the end he didn’t reach a conclusion and asked his viewers for their opinion.

I watched the video from a particular vantage point, because I use these tools every day. I work with Claude and ChatGPT together, each one checking the other. At work, at GSC, I use them to build prototypes, update documentation, make sense of the many texts written in Ukrainian, and cross-reference information across a huge number of documents. At home, this blog has expanded to nine languages, and I’ve picked my dog game back up: on one side I’m migrating it from Blueprint to C++, on the other I’m laying the groundwork for the mechanics and game feel. The results genuinely surprise me.

In my view, the two Hungarians did the right thing. They built something they cared about and, before going public, they asked. What they made is legitimate. Mark is right to be concerned — Word Play still brings in revenue every month — but if I were in his position, I’d see it as an opportunity. Two people who’ve put hundreds of hours into your game, who know it inside out and have already built the features you never got round to finishing: why not bring them into the original project? They could handle live ops, updates, new modes. Mark himself admits he was too burnt out after launch to keep working on it. That strikes me as a far more productive path than a video spent airing grievances.

Clone or homage?

Where’s the line? For me, cloning means “I don’t care about the thing itself, I only care about the outcome.” Inspiration — even outright copying — can be a wonderful way of paying tribute to what came before. Word Play itself comes from Balatro, which comes from Luck Be a Landlord, which comes from Slay the Spire.

The line is about how much you care that the thing actually exists, for its own sake. There’s really only one question worth asking: does this thing deserve to be made? The money and the followers come later.

There’s a moment in the video that stuck with me. Mark reads through the chat logs and sees Claude add twenty-one modifiers in one go — something that had taken him months to code. I understand the frustration, and it’s a perfectly natural reaction. A farmer today uses a machine to do what once took hours with a scythe. Nobody expects him to miss the scythe.

Mark also mentions Lucas Pope, the creator of Papers, Please, who stopped talking about his games before release out of fear of clones. That’s his call and I respect it. Even so, I’m convinced that people will always prefer a new Lucas Pope game to any potential clone of one. Players follow the author — their sensibility, their perspective, the way they see the world.

Then there’s the advice from a Valve executive: don’t rely on a single mechanic, because it’s too easy to copy. Advice — especially from people who aren’t in the trenches — should always be taken with a pinch of salt.

If your game finds a market, a single mechanic can be enough. The real work starts afterwards, when you have to sustain it. And this is where technology plays in our favour: today it’s affordable to grow games that previously weren’t worth maintaining at all. The very tool that’s worrying Mark could help him pick Word Play back up and finish the daily challenge and speedrun mode that, by his own admission, he left half-written in the codebase.

What I’m taking away from this

Mark received that email and was able to turn it into a video watched by a huge number of people, because years of work had earned him an audience. That’s the real asset: the people following you are waiting for your next game, and anyone can rewrite the code in twelve minutes. So let’s use these new tools to help the things that deserve to grow grow better.

What would you say to Mark? And what would you say to the two Hungarians? Feel free to reach out directly on LinkedIn.

Mobile F2P: How Small Studios Rewrote the Rules

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

I asked Claude to study 2.5 Gamers, the podcast by Jakob and Matej that dissects a mobile game every week. Here’s the prompt I used:
I want you to browse the most-viewed videos from the past five years, pull the transcripts, and go through the content carefully, word by word. Then write me a breakdown of mobile F2P trends over recent years, with a particular focus on games coming from lesser-known developers.

What makes this podcast compelling is that the main characters are often two-, seven-, twenty-person teams — frequently based in Turkey, Vietnam, China, or some small town in Northern Ireland — pulling in numbers that turn heads.

A note on figures: almost all the revenue numbers I mention are estimates made by Jakob and Matej using market intelligence tools. Treat them as ballpark figures.

2023: the rise of hybrid games

After Apple’s privacy changes, user acquisition costs climbed to the point where the hyper-casual model — masses of downloads at a few cents each, monetised purely through ads — stopped making sense. In early 2024, a Voodoo executive said it plainly: hyper-casual is dead as a business, and their entire prototype pipeline is now aimed at hybrid casual.

Hybrid casual means starting with an ultra-simple hyper-casual core and layering a meta on top of it: currencies, progression, events, battle passes, some in-app purchases.

  • SayGames set the template with My Perfect Hotel: over a year in soft launch, then 13 million installs in the first month.
  • Habby did the same with their action RPGs, building a template they reuse from one game to the next.

User acquisition has increasingly spilled over into design, to the point of actually driving it. Whiteout Survival by Century Games, for the first thirty minutes, is indistinguishable from an idle game. Then a “World” button appears and you realise you’ve been playing a 4X all along. They grafted a low-CPI idle game onto a deep strategy title, because idle sells cheaply in ads while the 4X monetises for years. You’re essentially building two games in one.

2024: core mechanics start to matter again

2024 is the year small studios prove that a fresh mechanic is worth more than any amount of market research.

  • Lessmore is a remote team of 17 people. The prototype for We Are Warriors was built by two people in two weeks, with zero market research: they believed in a moment-to-moment gameplay loop that nobody had done yet. Estimated result: around $200k a day from ads alone, with rewarded ads capped at two per day to stop ads from becoming the main strategy.
  • Quokka Games, based in Turkey, has about ten people. Screw Jam is a mash-up of three existing games: the nuts and bolts from Nuts & Bolts, the exit limit from Bus Jam, and the bench mechanic from tile-match games. Within four months it goes from zero to roughly $130k a day in in-app purchases.
  • Hexa Sort, published by Lion Studios, invents a new puzzle mechanic and builds the whole thing around advertising: ten-minute levels, rewarded ads that appear directly on the board when you need space, and an interstitial when you reopen the app.
  • Offline Games — a collection of solitaire, chess, minesweeper, and clones of well-known games, apparently made by a single person. Zero progression, zero currencies, virtually no ads. By July 2024 it’s hitting one and a half million downloads a day. No paid acquisition campaigns found anywhere: just solid ASO, a YouTube channel with trailers racking up tens of millions of views, and cross-promotion across its own apps. One line from the episode stuck with me: “maybe the answer to monetisation is not having one.”
  • The WeChat mini-game market has around 400,000 developers, 70% of teams have between 5 and 30 people, and a game takes two or three months to make. China is running one to two years ahead of the West.

2025: execution and speed

By 2025 the mood shifts. The ideas are out there, but the trend is to copy them fast — and in mobile, it looks like the winners are whoever executes that best.

  • Rollic becomes the master of “deterministic puzzlers” — levels that play out identically every time — and bets on many games doing one or two million a month rather than chasing a single Royal Match.
  • Block Blast by Hungry Studio, a small Chinese team obsessed with A/B testing, takes Tetris, strips out the time pressure, and turns it into a three-piece puzzle with dynamic difficulty tuned to each player. It becomes the second most downloaded game in the world.
  • Grand Games, a Turkish studio, takes water sort — a genre packed with low-effort games coasting on ads — and applies the same level of polish as Royal Match: effects, animations, the game immediately telling you when you’re stuck and offering you an extra bottle.
  • Falcon Games, in Vietnam, copies Royal Match’s events system wholesale and drops it onto a puzzle about sorting objects onto shelves, overtaking the games that had invented the genre.

To me, this is a clear sign of dwindling originality and creative ambition. The sector is increasingly being taken over by a pure-greed mindset.

2026: the sort genre and the 30-day window

By 2026, execution is optimised even further — the winning teams are the ones who move fastest.

  • Pixel Flow comes out of Loom, a Turkish team of 7–8 people who left Rollic. No investor wanted to back them — according to Akin Babayigit, because they hadn’t come from Peak, the “right” studio. They put in all their own money, ran UA themselves, and went from zero to over a million dollars a day in ninety days. Then Scopely acquired them. A one-to-one Vietnamese clone reached $140k a day within two months, before being pulled from the stores.
  • Cube Land by RotateLab, a remote Turkish team, arrives after about twenty released games with nothing to show for it. Idea in November, retention test in March, $300k a day six months later. They call it “volume of shots”: keep taking them.
  • Smash Fest takes its core from a mini-game inside a Toon Blast live event — a cannon shooting balls at physical structures — and turns it into a full game. It scales to 300k downloads a day. Within a month, seven clones drop from established studios. Pixel Flow had three months before being copied; Smash Fest had one. The advice they keep repeating is blunt: you’ve got 30 days to scale.

The creative arms race

If there’s one thread running through all four years, it’s the weight of ad creatives. Since 2023, the volume of videos a game needs to produce has kept growing. Vita Mahjong, a simplified mahjong game aimed at older players, produced 23,000 creatives in a single month. One example cited: 1,800 creatives tested to find one capable of sustaining a million in spend. The takeaway is “whoever executes at volume wins.”

AI has accelerated everything. Some Chinese studios claim to produce 70% of their videos with AI. But the same technology has reached smaller players too: Matej, who’s developing his own game solo, generated ten videos starting from nothing but the store link, in an hour and a half. His conclusion is that ten imperfect videos beat one perfect one.

And there’s a darker side to this, which needs saying. Ads featuring fake neurologists, falsified gameplay, Marvel and Nintendo characters used without permission, families freezing to death to sell a gardening game. The platforms do very little about it. It’s one of the reasons I look at this market with a mixture of admiration and unease.

What I take away from all this

Laid out in order, these three years tell me a few things I want to keep in mind.

The barriers to entry are low; the barriers to excellence are sky-high. Akin says it, and the facts back him up. Anyone can clone Pixel Flow in two weeks. Meowdoku copied an almost note-for-note sudoku that had been sitting on the market for eighteen months going nowhere, and made it explode. Block Out took the same mechanics as Color Block Jam with a completely opposite level design philosophy and surpassed the original. The idea gets you through the door; execution decides who stays.

Specialisation pays off. Loom came from years of deterministic puzzles. Malpa Games spent ten years sharpening their production on word games and sudoku before hunting for new ideas, because “ideas get copied immediately if you’re not precise and fast.” People who know a genre inside out spot where it can be pushed before anyone else does.

Fresh ideas come from outside the genre. A mini-game from a live ops event becomes a full game. A game for older players becomes a monetisation model. Township, after seventeen years, is a match-3 with a tycoon layer in front of it that exists purely to lower the cost of acquisition. “People don’t look outside their own genre,” they say in the Township episode. Those who do find room to move.

Organic reach still exists, but it’s the exception. For most small studios, distribution remains the core problem — and with AI bringing production costs down, it’s only going to become more so.

What reassures me, in all of this, is that the game still matters. Akin says the industry has swung too far towards data, and that today the ad networks’ algorithms raise the quality bar at launch: you can’t ship a half-finished game and test your way to success anymore. You need instinct. You need someone who knows what to keep and what to cut.

And for anyone working in design, that’s good news.

Five Uncomfortable Questions About the Video Game Industry

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

Over the past few months, the same questions keep coming up. The tone is almost always anxious. I’ve tried to line them up and answer them in my own way.

1. Are we making more games than the market can absorb?

Production capacity is growing, AI promises to push it even further, and yet players still have the same number of hours in the day. The argument seems to hold up.

And yet this past year, with one of the most packed release calendars in recent memory, told a different story. Players have far more time — and far more appetite to spend — than we give them credit for. You don’t need to finish a game to feel good about having bought it. Just look at your own Steam library: mine is full of games I’ve started, dropped, and will get back to eventually. Buying them is already part of the enjoyment.

The market absorbs well-made games just fine. What struggles in a crowded landscape is the mediocre game — the one that in a quieter year might have scraped by, and today disappears within a week. I’ve said it before and I’ll keep saying it: games are a form of art, and the people who play them can tell the difference between something made purely to sell and something made to say something unique.

2. Is this a funding crisis, or are we funding games by rules that no longer apply?

I lean towards the second. The industry has stopped growing at the pace it once did, and the investment models built on those growth curves have aged badly. Anyone pitching a business plan with 2020-style projections will rightly get the “heard it all before” look.

There’s something else that doesn’t get said enough. For years, the assumption was that putting someone from a big AAA studio in charge of a new team was a safe bet. Managing three hundred people inside an existing structure is one job. Building a studio from scratch, on a shoestring, with no safety net, is a completely different one. The string of ventures led by ex-Riot, ex-Blizzard alumni and so on proved that. Many promised a lot and delivered little, and investors haven’t forgotten.

Investors want to see clear distribution strategies that do something a bit different, ideally backed by solid numbers. And if your business isn’t built around growth but around building intellectual property, you’re better off looking at other funding models and saving yourself the headache.

3. If AI makes execution cheaper and faster, what’s left that’s defensible?

I’ll start by questioning the premise, because I’m not convinced. I think AI will make development bigger before it makes it cheaper.

Generating more assets and more code means someone still has to review them, test them, discard them, integrate them. The bottleneck shifts to revision and QA, and that’s where complexity balloons. Once the excitement dies down, we’ll see new specialised roles emerge just to keep all of this running — and the final bill will be higher than it is today. If I could previously develop one mechanic to a certain level, and now I can develop five simultaneously, that also raises the bar for the complexity players expect from us.

So what remains defensible? What’s always been there: the taste of the person who decides what to keep and what to cut, the relationship with your players, the ability to say no. The more material there is on the table, the more valuable the person who knows how to choose.

4. If no one is hiring juniors today, who will the seniors of tomorrow be?

This is the easiest one, which is precisely why it baffles me that people keep asking it. The companies that will still be here tomorrow are the ones investing in their juniors today.

Every single company that stops hiring juniors is making a choice that looks sensible on this year’s spreadsheet. If everyone does it, in five years the senior talent pool will be empty and eye-wateringly expensive. Those who invested in people when it was hard work will have an advantage that money simply can’t buy.

If you’re a junior, don’t lose heart — focus on making things, putting your voice out there, and meeting people. If you’re a founder, think about the future of the industry you live and work in.

5. Are we designing creative risk out of games?

Good design is a balance between what the player expects and a well-placed surprise that catches them off guard in just the right way. Strip out all the risk and you’re left with a game everyone recognises and no one remembers.

It’s natural for large companies to play it safe — they have a lot to lose, shareholders to keep happy, franchises to protect. But that caution leaves an enormous amount of space for anyone who’s small, fast, and willing to try something new. Every time the big players retreat into the safe formula, a door opens for someone else.

It’s worth always keeping the core fantasy of our games front of mind. Push against it with ideas drawn from other media. And be bold enough to bring those ideas in through your own creative lens — players tend to appreciate that far more than we expect.

Miyamoto Didn’t Write Code

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

From what I can gather, Miyamoto never wrote a single line of code for his games. In an old Iwata Asks, lead programmer Toshihiko Nakago describes how it worked. Miyamoto and Takashi Tezuka would sketch levels in pencil on enormous sheets of graph paper. Nakago’s team would then enter the data by hand, block by block. In the evenings they’d burn everything onto a ROM, and the two designers would play through the level. Corrections would come back as pencilled notes on the sheet. “We could barely manage one round of changes a day,” Nakago recalls.

One cycle a day. Today, with a language model open alongside the editor, I can run one every two minutes.

I’ve written before that the lone genius is a myth and I still believe it: without Nakago there would have been no Super Mario. Today, a language model handles part of what used to be that dialogue between designer and programmer. But the dialogue itself remains — and the way Miyamoto engaged with it says a lot about what our craft is becoming.

The designer as director

I like to picture Miyamoto as someone who knew what he wanted and knew how to communicate it. His job was to describe: where the block goes, how high the jump reaches, what the Goomba does when it hits a pipe. Translating that into assembly was someone else’s problem.

Something similar happens with AI. I can describe a mechanic, a character’s states, the edge cases, and get back a script for Godot or Unity that implements them. The quality of the output depends on how clearly I’ve thought things through — the more precise I am, the fewer tokens I’ll burn.

The designer decides what should happen, why, and what it should feel like. Writing the code becomes a part of the process you can hand off. I touched on this recently when writing about junior devs: the job has always been to instruct a machine until it becomes a game.

The limits of today

The NES had 2 KB of working RAM. Nakago describes hunting for free memory: with twenty bytes to spare, you could add ten more blocks to a level. Some of the most enduring solutions in gaming came out of those constraints — like the clouds and bushes in Super Mario Bros., which are the same sprite recoloured.

Miyamoto didn’t program, but he knew those limits inside out. That’s why what he asked for was always actually buildable.

AI has its own limits, and anyone using it needs to know them just as well. The model forgets whatever falls outside its context window. It gives different answers to the same question. If it’s running in real time inside a game, every call has a latency and a cost. Knowing these things lets you design around them — and sometimes turn them into mechanics: a character with a faulty memory, an unpredictable oracle, a world that shifts every time you visit it.

Ten cycles a day, then a hundred

In the same interview, Nakago mentions that with later tools they could iterate on a level ten or twenty times a day. Today the loop between idea, implementation, and playtest is compressed almost to nothing. I tweak the gravity, play it, tweak it again.

That shifts the bottleneck. Before, the constraint was how fast someone could implement a change. Now, the constraint is how fast I can tell whether the change actually works. And to figure that out, I have to play, feel, compare. The feel of a jump only reveals itself with a controller in your hands.

What AI doesn’t know

AI can write code, sketch dialogue, generate assets in seconds. But it doesn’t know when a level has gone on too long, when an enemy arrives at exactly the wrong moment, when a jump tips over from challenging into frustrating. It doesn’t experience joy, boredom, or tension. It’s good at imitating solutions others have already found; deciding which ones to keep is down to whoever’s actually playing.

That’s why I think the game designer’s value is shifting even further towards taste, pacing, and an understanding of player psychology. Those are the qualities that made Miyamoto’s work timeless — and he honed them with a pencil and a sheet of squared paper.

Three things to practise starting tomorrow

  1. Write specs that someone else can execute. Take a mechanic you know well — Mario’s jump, say — and describe it in ten lines. Then hand it to a model and see what comes out. Every gap between what you had in your head and what you see on screen is a place where your description was fuzzy.
  2. Learn your tool’s limits. Miyamoto knew the NES’s memory; learn what the model gets wrong — where it gets confused, what it forgets, when it starts making things up. That’s design-relevant information.
  3. Play more than you generate. When an iteration takes two minutes, it’s easy to crank out fifty of them without actually playing any. Set aside time to pick up the controller and make a proper judgement — and write down what you felt before you ask for the next change.

Games Like Toys

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

In the last few days I’ve written about what retains value when copying a game becomes trivial and about prototypes built by mixing existing games together. Today I’m coming back to the same territory, but from the audience’s side — prompted by two pieces of content that landed in my inbox almost simultaneously.

Taking apart and putting back together

The first is a video from the AI Search channel that explains how to use AI to decompile games and remix them with each other. Mirror’s Edge parkour inside Skyrim, Minecraft inside GTA, Spider-Man in a Batman game. The parkour port, the author says, took roughly a day. His summary:

“Think of it as like copying and pasting various elements from different games to create a completely new game.”

A lot of these mashups are rough around the edges — collisions and physics breaking all over the place. Almost none of them will ever become a product. And yet loads of people watch them, recreate them, and share them.

That’s what I find fascinating. For a certain segment of the audience, the game has become a toy. The objectives we design become optional; the fun is in opening the box, pulling out the pieces, and building something nobody planned for.

What they’re really after

The second is a long post by Seth Godin on which AI businesses are actually worth building. Godin writes that at the root of almost every purchase there are three drives: status, belonging, and freedom from fear. On top of that he places an intermediate layer made up of things like control, transformation, and belonging to a narrative.

The people making mashups live exactly in that layer. They want control over the game they love, they want to transform it, and they want to show it to people like them. Every community swapping these experiments around is a network effect that nobody had to pay for.

Then there’s the line that hit me hardest as a game designer:

“Mechanics without a story is the race to the bottom.”

Godin is talking about startups. It applies to us just as well. If a mechanic can be lifted out in a day, on its own it’s worth very little. The player is looking for the story that mechanic lets them tell.

Fallout’s dog in Human: Fall Flat

I tried looking at my own game, Pawtners Case, through this lens.

Take Dogmeat, the dog from Fallout 4 — the one you order to fetch items and bring them back. Drop him into Human: Fall Flat, the physics puzzle game from No Brakes Games where Bob wanders through his own dreams grabbing everything with floppy arms. The result looks a lot like Pawtners Case: a police dog in a dreamlike city, two buttons, objects picked up with the mouth, and physics that makes you laugh.

Today I could watch that mashup running before I’d written a single line of code. It would be a private, unpublishable prototype — and it would be enough to tell whether the feel works.

There’s also a detail I now read differently. In Pawtners Case every case can be solved three ways: noob, pro, and hacker. The hacker route is designed for players who exploit the physics and the levels to reach the end in their own way — in other words, for people who treat the game like a toy. I’d designed it as a bonus feature. Maybe it’s actually speaking to the most interesting audience of all.

So, is it a business?

For the people making mashups, almost never. For whoever gives them a legal sandbox, pieces to combine, and a stage to perform on — very likely yes. Roblox, Mario Maker, and Fortnite Creative have been proving that for years.

For game designers, the question shifts: how easy is it to take my game apart, and what will players build with the pieces?

The GDD Beyond the Template

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

When people talk about game design documents — about design documentation — they usually jump straight to templates and standard formats. In my view, that’s a missed opportunity to look at the bigger picture. Format is just one aspect of one of the five parts of good design documentation.

A few months ago I wrote about the difference between a document and documentation. This post picks up from there: once we’ve established that we’re documenting something concrete, what should the document actually contain?

Five perspectives

To keep things concrete I’ll use a simple example: the boost in a racing game.

Knowledge. First of all, a design document is built around a set of things the game — or the feature in question — should teach players. I’ve talked before about the player experience narrative, which is the story of the game or feature written from the perspective of an enthusiastic player. This helps us identify the components of what we’re describing, and therefore the skill atoms — the individual pieces of knowledge we’re trying to convey. Fun always comes from a process of discovery, much like a creative one: to play is to learn.

For the boost, the skill atoms might be: understanding when the bar is full, discovering that boosting through a corner causes you to lose grip, learning to save it for the final straight. Each of these is a small discovery, and each one needs to be described.

Objectives. Second, the document contains the objectives we have from the game’s perspective. These take the form of specific behaviours we expect from players, and sometimes emotions we want to evoke. You’d typically start from the game pillars (if you have them) and use them to articulate the goal you’re working towards.

For the boost, the objective might be that the player uses it at least once per lap and feels a rush of adrenaline on the straight. A pillar is only useful if it forces you to give something up: if the pillar is “speed”, the document should also say what we’re sacrificing to maintain it — for example, no menus during a race. And if we’re expecting a specific behaviour, we should also write down how we’ll measure it. An objective you can’t observe in a playtest or in the data is just wishful thinking.

Gameplay. Next comes planning the gameplay itself — making the player’s objectives concrete, along with the content, activities, and any strategies they might use to overcome obstacles. This is where you’ll most often find flowcharts, bullet lists, and so on.

This is where format comes into play. How we present the gameplay should serve whoever’s reading it. For the boost, a diagram showing the states (empty, charging, full, active) tells a programmer more than three pages of text, while a table with speeds and durations is more useful to whoever handles balancing. Format is chosen based on the content and the reader, and it can change from section to section.

Systems. A good design document can’t afford to ignore systems. A system is a group of mechanics that, together, teach the player something — which is why I see it as a collection of learning experiences. There are also unplanned dynamics that we can sometimes identify and that end up becoming part of the metagame.

Scott Mercer talks in a short video about how he designed Gruul the Dragonkiller, a boss from World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade. He wanted to recreate the feeling of musical chairs — when the music stops and everyone scrambles to find a seat. The first mechanic, Shatter, deals damage to players who are near each other, so players learn to spread out. Mercer immediately anticipates an unplanned dynamic: the raid might assign everyone a fixed spot, and all the fun would vanish. So he adds Ground Slam, which flings each player in a random direction and forces them to improvise. Then there’s latency: in 2007 many players were still on dial-up, and everyone saw others in slightly different positions. So he introduces a gradual slowdown, which gives clients time to sync up and, as a bonus, adds tension. Finally, the more players die, the more space there is to spread out, meaning the fight would get easier over time. A steady increase in damage keeps everyone motivated to stay alive.

Each mechanic patches a hole left by the previous one, and each one changes what the player is learning. That’s why, if the feature we’re documenting is part of a larger system — or affects other systems — we need to show we understand the bigger picture and make a genuine attempt to anticipate how it’ll behave. Back to our example: if the boost recharges by collecting items on the track, that also changes how the player chooses their line, and level design needs to know that.

Production. Finally, good design documentation helps resolve design problems and challenges, and guides programmers and artists in building all the assets needed for the feature or game to succeed. For the boost, that means listing visual effects, sounds, and camera movements, and flagging the open questions: what happens if the player activates the boost mid-jump?

Templates have their limits

When we focus too much on the final format, we risk losing sight of the bigger picture and leaving out parts that one template might cover and another might not.

Take the one-pager. It’s great for aligning a team or pitching an idea to a publisher, yet there’s no room in there for systems and their interactions. Many classic GDD templates, on the other hand, have sprawling sections on gameplay and nothing on the knowledge the player needs to acquire. When I choose a format, I already know which of the five parts I’m sacrificing, and I document it somewhere else.

That’s why I use the five parts as a checklist, before I even open a template: knowledge, objectives, gameplay, systems, production. If one is missing, the document has a gap — whatever format it’s in.

The Prototype Without a Team

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

This past weekend I was completely captivated by the stream of news about video game code decompilations. This came after a week of surprises, in which I discovered I can basically have an idea and see it come to life immediately. On my own, without asking anyone for their time.

Make your own mix

At work I built something that would have been unthinkable three months ago, but for obvious reasons I can’t go into it. In my personal life, I’m studying Catalan and I made a video game for my class, starting from an expression we use a lot: tros de quòniam, which roughly means “a person who’s not the sharpest tool in the shed”. In class we’d done a verb trivia game, so I asked my teacher if I could photograph it. Then, using all the free material available online, ChatGPT helped me structure my own version.

My idea was to keep the dice roll and add objectives to complete — like in mobile puzzle games — which drive much stronger engagement. There are four colours, one for each verb family. Each correct answer is worth ten points multiplied by the dice roll, and filling the bar lets you capture the “trosset” of that colour. Mistakes don’t set you back and there’s no timer, because the goal is to learn.

The start screen of Tros de Tríviam

When I think about it, there isn’t a single new element in this game. The class trivia game, the exercises from official sources, the dice, the progress bars from mobile puzzlers — all of it already existed. The creative work was deciding how to fit the pieces together. You can try it here, if you’re studying Catalan.

A game in progress: the four trossets to capture and the dice roll

What I’m seeing now is that people are using Claude to decompile games and mash them together. In the video below, for instance, someone merged EA’s Skate and Modern Warfare 2: the player can switch to third person, hop on a skateboard, and shoot enemies while doing it.

This is absolutely fascinating, and it breathes new life into the many mechanics that repeat from one game to the next.

I can picture a future where belonging to an ecosystem lets players try out whichever combinations appeal to them. You finish Spider-Man and Wolverine, then use each character in the other’s game. New life for what you’ve already bought. Really exciting stuff.

As a game designer, though, the first thing that springs to mind are the problems. Spider-Man is an acrobatic improviser — he hits and bounces between enemies, and his combat is designed with lots of space and spread-out foes. Wolverine’s combat is far more brutal and visceral, all close-quarters. Put Wolverine in Spider-Man’s New York and you immediately wonder how he moves between skyscrapers without webs. Put Spider-Man into Wolverine’s close-range brawls and his acrobatic rhythm has nowhere to breathe. Every game builds its enemies, levels, and camera around its protagonist’s core verbs. The most interesting mix is the one that forces you to rediscover a game you thought you already knew.

Thoughts on creativity

Some people might raise an eyebrow — fairly enough — at this avalanche of novelty arriving within the space of a few weeks. There are genuine ethical issues tied to all of this. For me, though, creativity somehow exists outside the reach of overly conscious logic and deliberation.

In one respect this situation resembles the question of chasing trends, which I struggled with a great deal working in mobile free-to-play. Chasing trends is a fundamentally anti-creative act. Being aware of trends certainly enriches your knowledge, but creativity is a process of discovery rather than an exact science. Those who chase trends always stay on the too-familiar side of things. A good mix starts from something the player already knows and adds just one surprise: familiar enough to get them in the door, fresh enough to keep them there.

In the same way, having these new tools available unlocks an enormous number of opportunities. Here’s a concrete example: before, to run some experiments and show the team I had a worthwhile idea, I’d have to ask the producers to assign me at least one artist and one programmer. Today I don’t need any of that. I’m not spending anyone else’s time, and that gives me a much wider space to explore. I can make five rough prototypes in an afternoon, throw four of them away, and discover things I didn’t even know I needed to ask.

Impossible to ignore

I use tools that are built on the large-scale appropriation of intellectual property, and that’s simply true. But the benefit from a purely creative standpoint is enormous. There are people more talented than me who could do without them — I can’t, and right now I’m not blocked.

My personal limit is to use them only for prototypes. I’ve written a story, La Principessa Melone, which I hope to publish in Italian in December. I illustrated it first with ChatGPT, and it was precisely those images that helped me understand what I was looking for — which then sent me looking for real artists to actually draw it. The prototype helped me figure out what I wanted, while the book itself will be drawn by human hands.

I don’t know how long this will last: there are various ethical and geopolitical questions that could shut down certain services within hours. So I wouldn’t recommend anyone build their strategy around any of this.

But it’s impossible to deny that we’re looking at a dazzling and in some ways incomprehensible situation, because everything is moving incredibly fast. My practical advice: prototype a lot and quickly, and keep anything that really matters out of a service that could be gone tomorrow.

If copying a game becomes trivial, what remains of value?

This post was originally written in Italian by Paolo Gambardella. It has been translated by an AI agent and may contain inaccuracies.

If copying game mechanics and entire systems becomes trivially easy, what’s left that actually holds value? I think the answer lies in live operations.

I’m coming at this from a very concrete experience. Six months ago I had to write prompts to get LLM services to do what I needed. Then I moved on to drafting markdown files with detailed instructions. Today I can just record a video, talk through what I want while moving things around on screen, and that’s enough. Each step has lowered the bar for turning an idea into something that actually works — and I don’t see why it would stop there.

Which inevitably leads me to think we’re approaching a point where a progression system, a game loop, or a well-crafted mechanic can be replicated in a matter of days. Code and design ideas stop being a lasting advantage. What you can’t copy with a video, though, is the work that happens after launch: the seasonal events, the updates, the way you listen to your community, the relationship with the creators who tell your game’s story. Live operations are made of people and time, and time can’t be duplicated.

Something similar happened with music. Musicians went from playing live only, to playing on the radio, then to recording albums, and finally to digital platforms where they make practically nothing. How do you survive? By playing live. For them it was a return to the beginning — almost an unavoidable choice.

In our case, though, it’s an evolution, because nobody is forcing us to go back. The long-term winners are always the ones who manage to carve out a niche, to build their own audience. And this will only become more pronounced. Since dropping in new mechanics on the fly is becoming trivially easy, the real difference will show in the narrative that tomorrow’s studios know how to build with their audience as they go. I’m thinking of studios that document development as it happens, that show their decisions and their mistakes, that make players feel like part of a story still being written. Improvising a narrative means exactly that: building it together with people, day by day, rather than packaging it once before launch.

The game itself can be copied by anyone, sooner or later. First it was only companies of similar or greater size who could do it — now it’s genuinely anyone. The audience that follows you from the very beginning, on the other hand, can’t be duplicated.